I approach the appreciation of music from a certain ideological standpoint which, however much I might ramble about it, boils down to this: good music is good music. Obvious right? Well it would seem to be until you consider how many people make the choice (and it is a choice) to close their minds and cover their ears. This could manifest itself as the resolute confinement of their listening habits to the first genre of music they ever enjoyed or it could be the stigmatization of individual genres. It could be the notion that all new music and new bands that came about after a certain point in time are no good or it could be the equally ridiculous notion that music only got good from another certain point in time.
Me I’m a fascist for open-mindedness. Every type of music from any age has the potential to be great. It is simply the idiots making bad music within any given genre that are the problem. I used to think there was a time when I would never appreciate Country, R’n'B or Black Metal. Not any more. This isn’t thanks to Garth Brookes, R. Kelly and Cradle Of Filth I can assure you, it’s down to finding artists in those genres making intelligent, credible music with integrity and passion.
So far so “look how fucking awesome I am for being so fucking open-minded THE REST OF YOU SHOULD BE ASHAMED! STOP LISTENING TO ADELE AND CONVINCING YOURSELF YOU ARE ACTUALLY ROLLING IN THE DEEP ALONG WITH HER ON YOUR WAY TO WORK I CAN SEE YOU NODDING AWAY IN YOUR CARS!”
(I do quite like Adele really. I’m open-minded like that).
Yes anyway, I attempt to approach all music from a neutral starting point and judge it on its own merits. The thing is I know this to be impossible. The appreciation of music is a subjective matter, and even with the best will in the world you cannot go into that type of field without some level of prejudice or preset ideas present within you. And a perfect example of this presented itself to me on the bus home today.
I had not listened to As Tall As Lions eponymous second album (2006, Triple Crown Records) for probably around eight months. It’s an album that I have loved for several years without really having made an effort to learn anything about the band. I hadn’t read any reviews, hadn’t seen any media coverage hadn’t spoken about the band with anyone who knew anything about them. I’d just come across the album, listened to it and fell in love. Coming back to it today I was suddenly taken by just how gentle some of the music was, and then by the melancholia of the romance in the sound. I started to think about trying to describe just why I loved the album, perhaps in anticipation of writing a piece about it to publish here. I found myself for the first time trying to place ATAL in a bracket with other music and other bands, maybe even within a genre and the first band that came to mind was Coldplay. It honestly came as quite a shock when I suddenly opened my ears to the similarities between the bands. I’m not going to spell them out here, that’s not what this article is about, but if you listen to the ATAL album you’ll hear them quite easily. (The real point anyway is that ATAL, given the right breaks, could sell the same kind of units as Coldplay).
Now, I don’t have an active dislike of Coldplay. I think they have some good songs (The Scientist, Speed Of Sound), some very bad songs (In My Place, Fix You) and some songs somewhere in the middle (the ones I haven’t bothered to listen to yet. Yellow). I’m also not about to argue they are actually as good as ATAL (listen to Stab City to render any kind of debate on this point redundant). Nor are they exactly the same type of band – ATAL are more dynamic and a bit more up-tempo across the length of the album.
Well what are you trying to say then you rambling pleb?
I’m trying to say that my approach to a band like Coldplay - mainstream indie, popular, vastly uncool – is tainted by the very way in which I perceive them. And that worries me. What if it had been ATAL who had sold millions of albums and had the blanket coverage and appeared on the cover of The English Magazine (that’s Q by the way, I’m going for a Macbeth thing there) and what if Coldplay were a band I’d chanced upon in a second-hand record shop that I’d never heard anything about? Would I be telling you right now that ATAL are ok but not a patch on Coldplay (listen to Clocks to render any kind of debate on this point redundant)? Due to my puny mind being subjective it is impossible to say. This does however bring up a couple of interesting questions about perception of an artist that revolve around saturation of coverage.
Firstly, and I think this is something that every music fan is guilty of, there is the ‘I’ve found this band…’ syndrome. To me this is a remnant of discovering new music when you’re actually discovering music itself. The first few times when you felt a connection with a band that your friends didn’t already know about or that you hadn’t heard on daytime radio or seen on the cover of a magazine; for me this was part of starting to flesh out my own identity. I probably spend more time looking for new music now than ever before and I do love to turn other people onto the music I hear that I think they will like. I do it because I want them to hear this great music that I think will enrich their lives but I’d be lying if I wrote that there isn’t a little part of me who loves being the guy in the know. Oh yeah Sleigh Bells, I heard their demo back in 74 don’t you know… You can’t turn someone onto a band who have already sold four million albums. Well you can but there’s either something wrong with you or the person you’re telling…
This brings me to the second point – how does your perception of how cool a band are effect your appreciation of them? I’d love to say not at all, because it really shouldn’t, but it probably does. Lets take another two bands, say Emery and Lost Profits (I’ve done that on purpose which might give you a clue as to which band is going in the decidedly not cool category here). I’ve chosen Emery because I see them as an average kind of band, some good tunes, some filler, rather than band I really like, who have a kind of similar sound and structure to their music as Lost Profits. This is because I have a pretty solid opinion of how much I actively dislike LP. Here’s the point: having never heard of Emery and then coming across their In Shallow Seas We Sail album I probably listened to it eight or nine times, enjoying it for what it was without getting too much from it. If you asked me what I thought of Emery I’d tell you I thought they were ok but nothing special (this track is mint though). If we again transplant LP into Emery’s position here then I imagine that there might be enough hooks and not entirely shithouse songs on one of their albums (I’m not including Fake Sound OF Progress here but neither do I want to talk about it. Still a lot of bitterness on both sides…) for me to have a similar listening experience with them as I had with In Shallow Seas We Sail. What do you think of shitty old Lost Profits? I think they’re ok but nothing special.
This is all conjecture. I really do think LP are rubbish from as objective a point of view as it’s possible for me to take. This is based on having listened to their output over several years rather than a judgement made because of how successful they have been, the way they look, their lack of integrity, shoddy live performances or generic, maximum potential-sales minimum artistic invention ideology. I think they are fucking rubbish (not all that objective probably that there point of view) . But the point that troubles me is if I had come across them purely on a music only playing field, would my opinion be different?
Questions that can’t be answered but I think are worth taking the time to ask. You’re never too on the button to ask yourself – “Am I being a pretentious twat?” The important thing to take away, for anyone still reading, is that As Tall As Lions really are fucking excellent. Gentle, romantic, crooning, melancholy brilliance. Give them a listen to hear how it’s really done. All together now “…and maybe I had too much wine, I hope you come back to mine…”